16 Sep 2001
First of all, I've heard from my immediate family and everyone seems to be accounted for ok and although everyone also seems to know someone among the missing. I grew up in NY and went to college in Manhattan. I spent one of the most formative years of my life sitting on the roof of our 20-story dorm and staring downtown at the view of the towers. It's really hard to wrap my mind around the fact that they are gone, never mind the human tragedy that continues to unfold.

Today I took an overnight bus to Malaysia, which being a somewhat Muslim country might not seem like the most sensible place for an American to be, but then again maybe it is?

My bus arrived at 3 a.m., so I napped in the bus station until things started to open up and I could check my luggage and go for a bit of breakfast and errands. Ironically, today seems to be some sort of a national holiday in Malaysia and flags are flying everywhere.

I'll admit "national holiday" wasn't my first guess as to the cause of the flags, but realization of my paranoia helped to settle my nerves for the afternoon bus ride to the quiet little town of Mersing.

I missed the last ferry to Tioman and so checked myself into a backpacker sort of hostel. They gave me lots of instructions on what to do with the wad of keys that came with the room, but I'm pretty sure locking them in the room wasn't on the list.

What at first seemed a minor foible got more serious when I realized that the 1st floor internet cafe/office had closed and I needed a key to get out of the building! I killed an hour or so watching Malaysian language coverage of the situation in New York while waiting to see if the internet cafe would reopen, but there was no sign of anyone else in the building.

Plan B had me discovering that the room next to mine was unlocked and it was just a short crawl on a third-story ledge to my open window. Welcome to the new world order.

17 Sep 2001
Catch the ferry to Tioman and check in for my five-day live aboard trip to dive some of the deep WW II wrecks in the area.

18-22 Sep 2001

Four inch anti-aircraft gun on the HMS Repulse.
My buddy tried once more to wriggle through the hole before finally giving up and flashing me an exasperated signal. His closed circuit rebreather just wasn't going to allow him through the narrow opening. At 50 meters (165 feet) with precious seconds and breathing gas slipping away I quickly made the decision to continue the dive alone.

I confirmed my ersatz buddy agreed with this, then rapidly clipped my camera and tank of decompression gas to the line I would trail behind me into the wreck. A final forlorn glance from Tim and I wriggled through the hole and up into the wreck.

The entrance must have been an ordinance hatch because inside I found a tangle of heavy equipment designed to load and transport the ship's mammoth 15-inch shells. Struggling to orient myself in the upside-down battle cruiser I carefully wound my way through the machinery vainly trying to arrange my guideline so that it would be safely navigable in the absolute darkness of a silt-out or torch failure. Squirming through a final small gap in the Rube Goldbergian mechanism I won through to a corridor and followed it deep into the ship.

Bathtub on the ceiling (floor?) of the inverted HMS Repulse.

At this depth I'm breathing the gas from my tanks at six times the pressure at sea level. Oxygen isn't a problem, but my body absorbs huge quantities of nitrogen, and even more quickly takes on the expensive helium I've added to the mix to keep my head clear on this complicated dive.

I carry decompression plans for several different bottom times. These sets of carefully timed stops at ever shallower depths and breathing increasingly oxygen rich gas mixtures will allow the excess nitrogen and helium to safely off-gas. If after my planned bottom time of 30 minutes I was to ascend directly to the surface without doing these stops my blood would froth and boil like a violently shaken bottle of soda. Assuming of course that I can find my way outside the wreck to begin with.

Me at 60m (200ft), with the screws of the HMS Prince of Wales in the background.

Overhead environments are one of the leading causes of fatalities for experienced divers. A sharp edge could easily cut my guideline and even a successful search for the exit might put me over my planned bottom time leaving me short of gas to complete my decompression. Add to the brew a torch failure, or a carelessly placed fin silting out the room and you begin to see why the error chains are short in this sort of diving.

Even my own breath is potentially fatal. The bubbles I exhale could dislodge debris from the ceiling, at worst causing a complete collapse and at a minimum stirring up silt to the point that even with a torch there is absolutely no visibility. In a silt-out the idea is to follow the line by touch to the exit, something that sounds eminently practical when read from a book, but is fabulously difficult in practice.

Gliding down the corridors of this once mighty warship my thoughts wander to just how alone I am. Even without any sort of problem, I stirred the silt up quite badly working my way through the wreckage of the shell transporter. On my way out I'll have to negotiate that bit by feel, inch by inch, being cautious not to gash myself or my equipment on the innumerable sharp edges. This delicate operation must be done in absolute blackness while maintaining control of my buoyancy and keeping track of the time and my gas supply.

Decompressing on the shot line. Divers on deco bars are visible in the lower left corner.

For this sort of diving one third of the breathing gas is allocated for going in, one third for coming out, with the final third considered to be the absolute minimum that must be reserved for contingencies. There are many cases, (such as searching for an exit in a silt-out) where that one third reserve has proven woefully inadequate.

The fact that my dive has been carefully planned and that I am properly trained and equipped does little to allay the knowledge that I am far out in harm's way, albeit not quite as far out as were the original Force Z sailors.

The British battle group known as Force Z consisted of the battle cruiser Repulse and the battleship Prince of Wales as well as the escort destroyers Tenedous, Electra, Express and the Australian man 'o war Vampire. On December 10, 1941, just a few days after the American debacle at Pearl Harbor, Force Z came under intense attack by Japanese bombers.

At 11:18 the first wave of high level bombers came over the fleet. There were a few minor hits, but nothing like what was to follow. Subsequent waves of torpedo bomber attacks proved devastating. The Prince of Wales was quickly disabled, one of her propeller shafts bent and the steering mechanism disabled.

Coral on the hull of the Seven Skies.
The battleship crippled, the bombers turned their attack on the Repulse. The captain managed to evade 19 torpedoes before he was caught in pincer attack by two groups of bombers. At 12:35 the Repulse took five torpedo hits and sunk in minutes taking 513 sailors to the bottom with her.

By this time the Prince of Wales had taken six or seven torpedo hits and was probably already doomed, but a final flight of high level bombers delivered the killing stroke. At 13:25 the great ship capsized and sunk with 327 men still on board.

In current day Britain, diving these wrecks and other so-called "war graves" is a contentious political issue. On one side are veteran's groups who are justly unhappy about the idea of divers rifling the wrecks for souvenirs. On the other side are responsible divers who come with a "take only photos leave only bubbles" ethic and are enthralled by the history and challenge of diving these wrecks. Between these two extremes are all manner of scalawags, ranging from the sport diver on the look out for the occasional artifact to commercial salvagers who have gone so far as to remove one of the Repulse's screws for scrap.

Turtle resting on the upturned hull of the HMS Repulse.

Deep inside the Repulse, these issues are far from my mind. I'm aware I might stumble across human remains, but it's not at all what I'm seeking. Rather, I enjoy the experience and challenge of going someplace that few will ever be.

Swimming down the corridor of the overturned ship I frequently check my gauges and note that my "one third of gas" turn around point is approaching. As I begin mentally rehearsing my exit I shine my torch forward for one last look and am startled to discover the largest moray eel I've ever seen poking out from the wall.

Morays are generally shy and non-aggressive, but this one is as big around as my thigh and in the tight confines of the ship who can tell. With forward passage blocked and with my turn point imminent, I quickly spin around in the corridor and begin reeling myself in back along the line.

Everything goes smoothly and the silt has even settled somewhat as I retrace my path through the shell loading equipment. Back outside the wreck I breath a sigh of relief even though my accumulated hour of required decompression time is just as dangerous a ceiling as the steel walls of the wreck. With my camera and tank of decompression gas quickly retrieved I have a few minutes to wander the keel of the ship. Surveying the torpedo damage I'm surprised to discover a napping sea turtle, seemingly an awfully long ways from any sand in which to bury eggs!

Many technical divers have their own way of whiling away the time at decompression stops. My old trimix instructor, John Bennett, brings down sections of paper back books and then sets the pages adrift as he finishes them. I usually spend the time in quiet contemplation, reviewing this dive, and planning the next one.

We began this trip on an unidentified wreck. It's suspected to be a British oiler but there is no record of its loss and so far no identifying markings have been found. Other than the mystery it's an unremarkable ship and the visibility wasn't great for our dives, but it made for good warm-up dives, a chance to settle in to the twin tank rig before the longer penetration dives to come.

Flying bridge of the supertanker Seven Skies.

Our second day was spent on the Seven Skies a 98,000-ton Swedish built supertanker that sunk on her maiden voyage. One of the tanks just forward of the superstructure exploded in what was either an insurance scam or a fairly colossal blunder.

I thought the diving here was excellent. On our first dive we dropped into the engine room which is absolutely mammoth, several stories tall and filled with all manner of heavy machinery on a Brobdingnagian scale. Of particular interest was one of the huge boilers crushed like a tin can by the pressure at 45m (150ft).

On our second dive we toured through the crew's living space. Room after room of shelves still chock full of everything needed to venture out on the sea for weeks at a time. We even found some sort of locked equipment cage, or maybe a bursar's office? There is always an eerie feeling touring these now underwater living spaces, a sense that time has stopped and frozen everything in place, just waiting for the crew to return.

From the Seven Skies we moved to the Battleship Prince of Wales, sunk in the same battle as the Repulse. The Prince of Wales lies in 70m (230ft) feet of water. At that depth the amount of oxygen in normal air is toxic, so the wreck is best dived hypoxic mixes of gas. Because of this added complexity and expense she is infrequently dived and I was quite excited about the opportunity.

Like many top-heavy battleships she has sunk upside-down, but luckily, with a slight lean so that amidships the deck on one side is a few meters off the bottom. Sadly, we wasted a lot of air trying the wrong side first, so that by the time we found the gap there wasn't enough gas left to attempt a penetration.

Steve unfurls his flag on the HMS Repulse.

After only a single dive on the Prince of Wales we moved to the Repulse. Lying in a more accessible 53m (174ft) of water the Repulse is an amazing dive. She also sank upside-down, but at a much more accessible 120-degree angle. She is a beautiful ship with graceful lines and bristling with the weaponry that only just slowed her fate.

At the Repulse was another dive boat on an expedition sponsored by the British military. There had a film crew aboard that seemed to devote an awful lot of attention on us, presumably to be cast as the villains in their documentary? Their ostensible objective was to lay wreaths and plaques and to conduct a general survey of the ships condition, but, the scent of boondoggle was in the water as all I saw them do was zoom around in circles on underwater scooters.

For our part, we did a dismal job of acting villainous as my dive buddy, Steve, was a Veteran of the British service and brought an ensign of his own to leave on the wreck.

Conning tower of the Dutch submarine K-17.

We extended our stay on the Repulse to four dives over three days before weighing anchor for our final dive on the Dutch submarine K-17.

The current was ripping at the submarine and here I had my only incident of the trip. I rounded the bow of the submarine running low on both planned bottom time and air, but I misjudged the distance to the tag line that would lead me to my planned ascent route, up the ships anchor line.

I ascended up through the thermocline to where I could see the anchor line, but there was no way for me to reach it in the strong current. A problem, but one I had plans for dealing with.

Using my reel I launched a surface marker buoy to the surface alerting the boat crew that I'd be doing a drifting decompression and giving me a support to maintain the precise depths required.

I'd been planning to decompress with 100% oxygen supplied from boat, but now I would have to do a longer series of stops using only the 50% oxygen I carried with me. After more than an hour of decompressing in the current I surfaced miles from the boat and was thankful that my buoy had been quickly spotted and a dingy sent to drift with me. A demonstration of the importance of backup planning, and a shaky end to and otherwise great trip.

I suppose there are those who will never understand why divers would want to take on the risk and expense of visiting deep wrecks, but for me it is the best sort of diving. At ease with my equipment, experience and training, I get to visit sites of great beauty and history. That people have died on these ships is a sad fact, and I myself have no intention of disturbing their rest. But how better to remember them and the reasons for their deaths then by visiting the site of their legacy on the bottom of the sea.

Nets shrouding the unknown British oiler.

Force Z Survivors Association
Lots of historical information, and the "no diving" perspective.
Wreck Respect web page
Presenting the diver's perspective.
B&J Diving Centre
Organizing trips to the wrecks.

   Home - Travel - Climbs - Cats - Friends - Links - Resume   
   Text and photographs are copyright 1994-2003 Evan Bigall, all rights reserved.